Every few years an attempt is made to implement something and then it dies a death.
Whichever system chosen is all stick and no carrot.
I went through hell a few years ago when we had a Head who was desperate to rid the school of all staff over 50.
I was set three objectives, all impossible, they were as follows.
1) All consumables are to be locked securely away and be easily accessible at all times to all staff!
Total bollocks as the two things are contradictory.
2) My room was to be subject to random spot checks and had to be tidy at all times.
The checks were always done after I'd left for the day! I started taking a photo on my phone every day as I left to show that I'd left the room tidy.
3) I was to show a more positive attitude.
I told my line manager that I was positive I was being shit on!